In the wake of 9-11, security experts wanted more data to detect threats to security. In the explosion of data collection that followed, it became obvious that more data created more noise, perversely in some cases making it more difficult to see embedded threats rather than less. More is not always better, and data is meaningful only if a.) you're measuring the right things, and b.) you know the … [Read more...]
Still Amusing Ourselves to Death: Information as Cautionary Tale
It might seem like our current information glut is without parallel, but throughout history observers have worried about the impact of too much information on our ability to rationally process and make sense of it. When we moved from an oral storytelling culture to print with the invention of the printing press. Or with the invention of the telegraph, which allowed our thoughts to be transmitted … [Read more...]
Classical Music’s #MeToo Stories Are Just A First Step
This week Washington Post arts journalists Anne Midgette and Peggy McGlone published results of their six-month investigation of sexual harassment in the classical music business. Some of the stories they put on the record were new; others have been open secrets for years. One of the latter stories - about Cleveland Orchestra concertmaster William Preucil is not new at all. Back in 2007, the … [Read more...]
Killing NEA, NEH And PBS Is Just Collateral Damage In The Commodification Of American Values
So it begins. A report in The Hill, then picked up in the Washington Post, says that the Trump administration intends to eliminate the National Endowment for the Arts and the National Endowment for the Humanities and sell off PBS. It's part of a plan to cut some $10.5 trillion over the next decade. Zeroing out the culture budgets isn't about money; together, the NEA, NEH and PBS account for … [Read more...]
So What Exactly Is A “Quantitative” Measure Of The Arts?
Arts Council England says it will use a standardized assessment system called Quality Metrics in evaluating the arts it it considers funding. The system has been developed over several years and is an attempt to create a matrix by which arts experiences can be measured and evaluated. Here are the criteria: Self, peer and public: Concept: it was an interesting idea Presentation: it was … [Read more...]
When We Allow Technology To Police Our Culture…
Last year I was producing the live streaming of the Ojai Music Festival and we decided to use YouTube to carry the streams. In a small outdoor venue, the number of seats is limited to a few hundred, and streaming the concerts greatly increases the number of people who can hear/see the concerts. Typically, in the 48 hours after the stream, the audience about doubles the number who saw it … [Read more...]
Sorry – A (Respectful) Dissent On A Well-Meaning Statement On Arts Equity
I would say based on the thousands of stories we sift through every day at ArtsJournal, diversity and cultural equity (along with funding) are right now probably the biggest issues being talked about in the arts community. And rightly so. It's astonishing to see article after article documenting inequalities in gender, race, sexual orientation and age in our cultural industries. The … [Read more...]
We Asked: What’s the Biggest Challenge Facing the Arts?
Last week we conducted our first ArtsJournal poll, asking readers: What's the biggest challenge facing the arts? We had 3,191 votes, with the largest percentage - 37% - answering funding. Second at 24% was "relevance/changing tastes" followed by "diversity" at 15% and "leadership" at 13%. Technology came in a distant fifth at 4%. I will admit that the results surprised me a bit. Over the past … [Read more...]
If Dance Can’t Pay Its Dancers What Does It Mean To Be A Professional Dancer?
A survey of dancers in the UK last summer reported that "more than half of professional dancers earn less than £5,000 a year from their performance work." That's professional dancers. "The statistics also show that around 50% of dancers’ jobs pay less than the minimum wage, and that 70% of dancers have performed in 'unsuitable work environments' in the past 12 months." Add to this how short … [Read more...]
Are Arts Leaders “Cultural” Leaders?
The two terms sometimes get mixed up. They're not interchangeable. For the most part, the big cultural debates of our time take place without participation of our artists and arts leaders. If artists aren't participating - let alone leading - it's difficult to make the case that they're cultural leaders. Somehow, our public debates about values - and by extension, what our culture looks like - … [Read more...]