As Tyler Green noted today, American historical art is popping up all over:
The National Gallery, the Met, the Huntington and the Nelson-Atkins have all opened major American presentations this spring. (The Met isn’t done: Its American paintings and sculpture galleries open in 2011.)
Opening next year in Arkansas, Crystal Bridges (collections link here) is sure to transform the field.
In the meantime, Green wondered the following:
On a morning when an American president born in Hawaii to a Muslim
Kenyan father and a Kansasan mother is speaking about Islam, Israel and
the United States at Egypt’s Cairo University, while back home a Latina
visits Capitol Hill to drum up support for her landmark nomination to
the Supreme Court and while New Hampshire becomes the sixth state to
offer state-level marriage equality, does it make sense for our art
museums to present American art galleries that present American art as
it might have been considered in 1935?
Really, 1935? There wasn’t a great deal of enthusiasm for historical American in 1935. Let me first say I’m happy to have a dog in this race. When the Seattle Art Museum reopened in 2007, it was (for the first time) with an American wing. What is old hat in this material on the East Coast is less so in the West and especially in the Northwest, where its absence has been nearly total.
The problems in building these collections are dramatic. American historical art is now a big crowd pleaser. With the best material increasingly hard to come by, it’s tempting to offer second tier work from stars rather than shake up the field with first-rate work from lesser knowns.
Because it apparently went for the former, Christopher Knight found the Huntington lacking, here. So did a well-informed blogger going by the name of Los Angeles County Museum On Fire, here. (Who? Who knows? On the Web, nobody knows if you’re a curator at one of the institutions you deplore. Or not.)
(For this topic, we need Robert Hughes back at his peak. Failing that, we can reread American Visions.)
SAM shines in the quality of what it has collected. Starting late, it came on strong with the best material.
[Read more…] about The American historical art boom. Is it a bust? Not in Seattle.