November 5, 2019 | About Last Night

Various forms of the records-that-changed-my-life meme have been making the rounds lately, so I came up with my own version, which I call “The Twenty-Five Record Albums That Changed My Life.” For the next couple of weeks, I’ll be writing about one of these albums every weekday in the approximate order in which I first heard them.

16. Arturo Toscanini and the NBC Symphony, Debussy La Mer (Victrola)

A Wal-Mart, the first one outside Arkansas, opened in 1968 in Smalltown, U.S.A.. It was located a mile from my front door, an easy ride via bicycle, and it sported a good-sized record section, most of which was devoted to pop and country music—but not all.

Three bins were reserved for classical albums, many of them new releases from Victrola, RCA’s budget-priced classical line. They sold for $2.98 apiece, slightly less than twenty dollars in today’s money. I’d pretty much exhausted the classical stock at Collins Piano Company, and the only place from which it was then possible to order records by mail was the Columbia Record Club. Even though I was increasingly obsessed with rock and roll, I still loved classical music, and I’d acquired a fair-sized stack of Victrolas by the time I left for college.

Victrola was a reissue line, many of whose releases dated from the 78 era, the golden age of classical recording. For me that meant, first and foremost, Arturo Toscanini and the NBC Symphony. I’d read about Toscanini in B.H. Haggin’s New Listener’s Companion and Record Guide, in which he was described as the greatest of all orchestral conductors. Such categorical statements invariably excite young readers, so I went out and started buying Toscanini albums, all of whose simply but elegantly designed covers featured Robert Hupka’s dramatic black-and-white photos of the Maestro at work. The sound was a bit variable, but the performances were thrilling without exception, and I got to know most of the standard orchestral repertoire from Toscanini’s lean, intense interpretations.

Of all my Toscanini albums, the one that made the deepest impression was his 1950 performance of Claude Debussy’s La Mer. Save for Debussy’s “L’isle joyeuse,” which I knew from Horowitz in Concert, I had heard next to no French classical music, and Toscanini’s way with La Mer, a piece that he had played for Debussy himself, was breathtakingly lucid and transparent. In addition, I was no less fascinated by the idea that a piece of music could depict in sound the play of waves on the surface of the sea.

I accepted the contents of the New Listener’s Companion and Record Guide as holy writ for a long, long time to come. Like many of his young fans, I even corresponded with Haggin, who later recommended me to Ted Libbey, the editor of High Fidelity, for which I reviewed classical recordings until that magazine’s unhappy demise in 1989. By then, though, I’d moved to New York and met Haggin in person, and had long since figured out that whatever else he was, he wasn’t infallible. (Later on I served for a short time as his literary executor, but that’s another story.)

Be that as it may, I owe B.H. Haggin an immeasurable debt of gratitude, not merely for getting me into High Fidelity but for introducing me to Arturo Toscanini, Artur Schnabel, Joseph Szigeti, and other legendary musicians of the past whose faded, scratchy recordings I treasure to this day. And I owe a similar debt to Wal-Mart, without which my high-school record collection would have been much smaller and far less interesting.

(To be continued)

* * *

Arturo Toscanini and the NBC Symphony perform “Jeux de vagues,” the second movement of La Mer, in 1950:

Two concerts by Toscanini and the NBC Symphony, originally telecast live from Carnegie Hall on March 15 and 22, 1952. The programs include an excerpt from Franck’s Rédemption, Sibelius’ En Saga, two of Debussy’s Nocturnes, Rossini’s William Tell Overture, Beethoven’s Fifth Symphony, and Respighi’s Pines of Rome: