My drama column in today’s Wall Street Journal is devoted in its entirety to Classic Stage Company’s revival of Galileo. Here’s an excerpt.
* * *
Classic Stage Company, long one of New York’s most impressive Off-Broadway troupes, has been hitting the bull’s-eye with rousing consistency this season. Having just mounted a “Cherry Orchard” that topped my list of revivals in 2011, CSC has now gone on to crack an even tougher nut, Bertolt Brecht’s “Galileo.” Brian Kulick’s staging, in which F. Murray Abraham plays the Italian scientist who dared to pit the evidence of his eyes against the dictates of faith, is a profoundly and comprehensively satisfying achievement, the kind of show that sends you home feeling disinclined ever again to waste your time seeing anything less good.
Mr. Abraham is not, however, the star of the show. That honor belongs to Charles Laughton, whose translation of “Galileo” is being used in this production. Prepared in the closest possible collaboration with Brecht himself for the 1947 American premiere in Los Angeles, in which the star of “Mutiny on the Bounty” and “The Private Life of Henry VIII” played the title role, this English-language rendering of the second version of “Galileo” (there are three) is a wonder, a translation that is both speakable and memorable….
Why is so great a play so rarely performed in this country? Because Brecht conceived of “Galileo” as a grand pageant requiring a huge cast. In 2010 I saw a large-scale production of “Galileo” at Sarasota’s Asolo Repertory Theatre that was outstanding in every way, and it fielded a budget-busting cast of 24. The original 1947 staging, which transferred to Broadway later that year, used 34 actors. Mr. Kulick, by contrast, is presenting “Galileo” in CSC’s 180-seat black-box performing space with just nine actors, most of whom play multiple roles. While this intimate approach inevitably deprives “Galileo” of its cavalcade-like aspect, it also allows Mr. Kulick and his cast to enact the play with Shakespearean speed and directness. You feel as though you’re watching far-off historical events through Galileo’s own powerful telescope, an impression reinforced by Adrianne Lobel’s amazing set, which turns the theater into a miniature planetarium.
Mr. Abraham gives us a lean, sardonic Galileo (he looks almost like one of El Greco’s famished saints) whose avowals of the joys of the flesh never quite ring true. That, however, is the only false note in his performance, which conveys Galileo’s hope and anguish with absolute authority….
* * *
Read the whole thing here.