Archives for 2006

“It seems to me that music, generally speaking, is the proper language for philosophy.”

Aleksander Wat, My Century (courtesy of Anecdotal Evidence)

This week my entire Wall Street Journal drama column is devoted to DruidSynge:

In Ireland John Millington Synge is considered a great playwright. In America, however, he has vanished into the pantheon of half-remembered masters–none of his plays has been seen on Broadway since 1971–and even the Irish long preferred respecting him to performing him. It wasn’t until the Druid Theatre Company of Galway City started reviving his work in the ’70s that the author of “The Playboy of the Western World,” who died in 1909, once again became a hot ticket in the land of his birth.

Now Americans are getting a fresh chance to grapple with Synge. “DruidSynge,” a marathon presentation of his six major plays, just opened at the Lincoln Center Festival after a week-long run at Minneapolis’ Guthrie Theater. The plays, which run for a total of eight and a half hours (including a 90-minute dinner break), are staged by Garry Hynes, founder of the Druid Theatre Company and the first woman director to win a Tony Award. All six are performed on a powerfully evocative set designed by Francis O’Connor, a fog-filled, dirt-floored hut whose dead gray walls stretch upward to infinity. The results are a mixed bag, but the best parts are so good that you’ll forget the rest well before the long day closes….

No link. You know what to do: be cheap and buy today’s Journal, or be smart and subscribe to the online edition by going here.

“‘I hate music.’ His voice rises, and for the first time this evening he speaks with a hoarse intensity. ‘I hate this incomprehensible, melodious language which select people can understand and use to say uninhibited, irregular things that are also probably indecent and immoral. Watch their faces and see how strangely they change when they’re listening to music. You and Krisztina never sought out music–I do not remember you ever playing four-handed together, you never sat down at the piano in front of Krisztina, at least not in my presence. Evidently her sense of tact and shame restrained her from listening to music with you while I was there. And because music’s power is inexpressible, it seems to carry a larger danger in that it has the power to arouse the deepest emotions in people who come together to listen to it and discover that it is their fate to belong to each other.'”

S

Last week a friend took me to see Prairie Home Companion on a free pass. I went somewhat against my better judgment. Like anyone, I’m a fan of Robert Altman at his best. And like many, I’m a Garrison Keillor detractor. At the time we made the plan, I knew Keillor had written the script but wasn’t clear about whether I’d actually have to look at him. My friend, who as far as I can tell is neutral on the subject of Keillor but does hail from Lake Wobegon country, confirmed that Mr. Lawsuit would appear onscreen. “Oh well,” I wrote back, “we can bring tomatoes.” In the blink of an eye he responded: “I don’t throw tomatoes at Minnesotans.” A principled position that I had to respect, though I’m not at all sure there aren’t several Michiganders I would gladly pelt, given the opportunity, with whatever happened to be handy.

At the outset, I disliked the movie. Michael Blowhard has written with infectious enthusiasm about its meandering charm:

Weak on storyline and action, it’s nonetheless focused and controlled — more a “Tempest”-like poetic picture of life than a narrative: We live among spirits and archetypes; death and beauty are never more than a few steps away; gallantry, generosity, humor, and belief carry us through … It’s a jewelbox and a metaphysical romance, yet it’s fully inhabited and embodied, and it never stops rolling along.

This gets at the trademark naturalism of many Altman films, but in the early going of Prairie Home Companion that signal quality struck me as terribly staged. The scene backstage at the radio show (a fictional, small-time version of “Prairie Home Companion”) as on-air time approaches is barely controlled chaos, a classic Altman occasion. As in more persuasive such scenes in Altman’s oeuvre, we get overlapping conversations, a dozen subplots unfolding at once, and lots and lots to look at. In the midst of this cheerful frenzy, both the cheer and disorder seem centered on the singing sisters played by Lily Tomlin and Meryl Streep, who clatter in like a squall at the last minute. Sweet and tart, blithe and barely holding things together, they more than any other characters encapsulate the reigning mood and aesthetic of the radio show and of the movie itself. What a drag, then, when they start uttering gobs of exposition while doing their makeup. The genius of Altman’s naturalism, when it’s on, is that it doesn’t press explanations on you but lets you put things together gradually: who people are, what their relationships are to one another, what stories they trail behind him. When Tomlin and Streep launched on this character-establishing and backstory-telling torrent almost as soon as we’d met them, my heart sank. I thought the movie was going to be really bad–and guessed the culprit would be the script. I reached for my tomato. But I hadn’t brought one.

Good thing too, because the film eventually won me over–for the most part. The on-stage musical performances loosened things up considerably: they themselves are pure pleasure, and by virtue of the balance they provide, they make the more contrived backstage action more interesting. But even as the film grew lovelier and more absorbing, the mote that I kept wanting to flick away was the weirdly flat performance by Virginia Madsen as an angel of death or something. I shouldn’t blame Madsen; it was probably an unsalvageable role, though it is true that Kevin Kline spun another undercooked part into a little bit of incidental charm, at least, as Guy Noir.

Now to help me understand why Madsen’s angel was so objectionable, along comes Odienator at the group film and television blog The House Next Door with a great essay on angels of death in Prairie Home Companion and Bob Fosse’s All that Jazz. To his mind, Altman is soft-pedaling death, he’s not buying it, and it makes him miss the Altman of years past:

Later in the film, Dangerous Ginny comments that “the death of an old man is not a tragedy,” which led me to holler out, “Bullshit, Mr. Altman.” When Lola asks if he is concerned that this is the last show, G.K. says “every show is your last show. That’s my philosophy.” “Thank you, Plato,” Lola’s sister Yolanda (Lily Tomlin) sarcastically replies, saving grumps like me the trouble of talking back to the screen again.

…I am closer to 52 than 80, and more attuned to Broadway than Lake Woebegone; I know more about sex and self-destruction than the wisdom of age and the sense of entitlement one feels for living a long life. Most importantly, though, I also know something about being a grouch, and from that vantage point, Prairie‘s subtle exhortations to go gentle into that good night seem a false comfort from Altman to his fans–a reassurance that displaces his usual blunt honesty. For a movie whose cast includes a sexy reaper, Prairie is too smug and passive about dying. The mortal coil is unraveling from the show and its participants, yet Altman chooses to deflect a universal fear by pretending that death is a mere nuisance.

This is why Madsen is so terrible; her air-headed angel’s platitudes ring hollow in the Altman universe we’ve come to know. Would the younger Altman have let a character get away with such bullshit? This artist has never felt the need to embrace and console his audiences in the past, so why start now? Nashville‘s final number, “It Don’t Worry Me,” was about willful denial; the whole of Prairie is about acceptance, yet it feels like a denial as well. The palpable fear that this is Altman’s last movie is never honestly dealt with by the director’s stand-in, Keillor, nor the film itself. It seems almost as if Prairie thinks it holds the monopoly on dying, and that the show-within-a-movie is noble–and its demise a tragedy–simply because it’s been around for so long. Altman’s onscreen representative G.K. keeps pooh-poohing the distress his colleagues feel throughout their last show, going so far as to state that he doesn’t want to tell people how to feel about his legacy; but his relaxed attitude never feels true. Altman throws out a hopeful, interesting curve when dealing with the fate of Tommy Lee Jones’ character (a fantasy of how to deal with one’s enemies). Here is the mean Altman we know and love, lashing out at his critics, informing you of his perceived greatness and how much it’ll be missed once he’s gone. But the film treats it as a throwaway; as quickly as it arrives, it defers back to that transparent, dishonest lulling. If Prairie weren’t so concerned with coddling us, we’d deduce that it’s OK to acknowledge Death–just don’t go looking for it; wait until it shows up to pull your number.

Yes. Read the whole thing, and bookmark that blog because they are always posting something good.

Incidentally, my first ten Altman films, in (rough) order of preference: The Long Goodbye, McCabe and Mrs. Miller, California Split, MASH, Short Cuts, Gosford Park, Cookie’s Fortune, The Player, Thieves Like Us, The Gingerbread Man. I’ve only seen half of Nashville, sad to say, and half a movie never sticks.

I spent much of Thursday driving around the highlands of Boise in my rented car, then made my way to the Boise Art Museum for a sneak peek at Frank Lloyd Wright and the House Beautiful, which opens Saturday. As I drove I listened to Twin Falls, the new Deidre Rodman-Steve Swallow CD, and I couldn’t have made a better choice: Rodman comes from Boise, and Twin Falls is a sequence of lyrical duets for acoustic piano and electric bass in which she and Swallow evoke with great subtlety the stony landscapes among which I wandered all afternoon.

Once I got back to the hotel, I turned on my iBook and plugged into the Web, where I ran across a New York Times story about Jack Larson and Noel Neill, who played Jimmy Olsen and Lois Lane a half-century ago in the Superman TV series. Not only are they both alive and well, but it seems that Larson, who later wrote the libretti for operas by Virgil Thomson and Ned Rorem, lives in a Frank Lloyd Wright house in Brentwood, California. Charmed by the coincidence, I did a bit of Googling and quickly found a photo of Larson’s home, a gorgeous Usonian built in 1939. (It’s S. 272 in the Wright catalogue, if you’re interested.)

Later on I dined at the Milky Way with Dana Oland, a smart young ex-dancer who covers the arts for the Idaho Statesman. Should you ever find yourself in Boise, I strongly suggest you make a point of eating there, too. After dinner I headed out Warm Springs Avenue to the Idaho Shakespeare Festival to see Love’s Labour’s Lost, which ends with my favorite curtain line in all of Shakespeare: The words of Mercury are harsh after the songs of Apollo. You that way: we this way.

Now I’m packing my bag and regretting my imminent departure from Boise, with which I find myself much taken. Tomorrow morning I fly to Salt Lake City, change planes for Saint George, pick up another rental car at the airport, drive to Cedar City, and see three shows at the Utah Shakespearean Festival. I wish I could stick around for another day or two, but I can’t. I never can. No sooner do I find my bearings in one town than I’m off to the next one, looking for another aisle seat and another tasty meal. You that way: I this way.

Here’s my list of recommended Broadway and off-Broadway shows, updated weekly. In all cases, I either gave these shows strongly favorable reviews in The Wall Street Journal when they opened or saw and liked them some time in the past year (or both). For more information, click on the title.

Warning: Broadway shows marked with an asterisk were sold out, or nearly so, last week.

BROADWAY:

– Avenue Q* (musical, R, adult subject matter and one show-stopping scene of puppet-on-puppet sex, reviewed here)

– Bridge & Tunnel (solo show, PG-13, some adult subject matter, reviewed here, closes Aug. 6)

– Chicago* (musical, R, adult subject matter and sexual content)

– The Drowsy Chaperone (musical, G/PG-13, mild sexual content and a profusion of double entendres, reviewed here)

– The Lieutenant of Inishmore (black comedy, R, adult subject matter and extremely graphic violence, reviewed here)

– Sweeney Todd (musical, R, adult subject matter, reviewed here)

– The 25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee* (musical, PG-13, mostly family-friendly but contains a smattering of strong language and a production number about an unwanted erection, reviewed here)

– The Wedding Singer (musical, PG-13, some sexual content, reviewed here)

OFF BROADWAY:

– Jacques Brel Is Alive and Well and Living In Paris (musical revue, R, adult subject matter and sexual content, reviewed here)

– Pig Farm (comedy, PG-13, some sexual content, reviewed here, closes Sept. 3)

– Slava’s Snowshow (performance art, G, child-friendly, reviewed here)

CLOSING SOON:

– Faith Healer (drama, R, adult subject matter, reviewed here, closes July 30)

– Susan and God (drama, PG-13, adult subject matter, reviewed here, closes July 30)

“I am thinking that people find truth and collect experiences in vain, for they cannot change their fundamental natures. And perhaps the only thing in life one can do is take the givens of one’s fundamental nature and tailor them to reality as cleverly and carefully as one can. That is the most we can accomplish. And it does not make us any the cleverer, or any the less vulnerable.”

S

“I HAVE a vast deal to say, and shall give all this morning to my pen.

“As to my plan of writing every evening the adventures of the day, I find it impracticable; for the diversions here are so very late, that if I begin my letters after them, I could not go to bed at all.”

That is the opening of one of Evelina’s early letters to her guardian, the Rev. Mr. Villars, in Fanny Burney’s 1778 novel Evelina, Or, The History of a Young Lady’s Entrance into the World. I find myself much in the same situation trying to blog this week, forced to choose sleep over blogging in the interests of self-preservation. But I have a vast deal to say, and shall give all this evening to my keyboard. So look for updates then.