I’m totally with OGIC on M.F.K. Fisher (see immediately below). I think she’s the American Colette, another wonderful writer whom some dried-up anhedonic types Just Don’t Get. I’ve introduced a dozen close friends to her work over the years, and not one has failed to warm to her. This isn’t to say that you absolutely have to like Fisher (or Colette) if you want to be my friend, but apparently it doesn’t hurt.
As for critics who poke holes just to hear the pop, that’s awfully undergraduate, don’t you think?
When I was an undergraduate, studying music criticism with the late John Haskins, who was then the music critic of the Kansas City Star, I brought in a paper for his perusal in which I declared that I didn’t like Schumann. He said, mildly, “You know, Terry, that says more about you than it does about Schumann.” As I pulled the arrow out of my forehead, I realized that I’d just learned a priceless lesson: if you’re going to express a personal prejudice in a review, one that causes you to dissent decisively from a long-standing verdict of posterity, do it ruefully, in full awareness that your inability to appreciate an obviously great artist is a failure of taste that separates you from the communion of truth.
(And no, Wagner doesn’t count.)