The great fifth season of Buffy the Vampire Slayer will be available soon on DVD. You can make a case for any of the seasons between the second and the fifth being best. Put me on the spot and I’ll squirm and equivocate, and in the end take the fifth.
The fifth season begins and ends with two great, jaw-dropping surprises. Although the second surprise is bigger, the first one is gutsier; it’s completely disorienting, yet (eventually) satisfyingly accounted for. (It won’t be obvious what’s so surprising about it unless you’ve watched the previous seasons.) In between, the Slayer faces her mightiest opponent yet. True, every next Big Bad has to be tougher than the last, but by the fifth season the show had just about topped out in terms of magnitudes of villainy–there wasn’t much of anywhere to go after Glory’s high-heeled predations. Actually, the sixth season came up with a resourceful and potent solution to this built-in dead end; unfortunately, the individual episodes had become uneven and unreliable by then, lurching from classics like the musical “Once More with Feeling” to terrible clunkers about mystery meat.
If you’re like many friends of mine who missed out on Buffy during its run, but want to see what all the fuss was about, I have some advice. Start with the second season. The first season has its charms, but it’s different in character from the following seasons and is not the best introduction. Plotwise, there’s nothing you can’t follow in the second season without having watched the first. If you like the second season, go back and watch the first before you pick up again with the third, and then it’s smooth sailing ahead for a good sixty-some episodes before things start falling apart.
About Last Night: you ask, we deliver. Particularly if you ask in verse.